Man, sometimes you just need a proper distraction. You know how it is. Last week, I was trying to fix this rattling sound coming from my washing machine—a noise that sounded suspiciously like a loose bolt plotting my ruin. After three solid hours of getting nowhere, I just closed the garage door, grabbed a cuppa, and needed something totally different to focus on. Something mindless, maybe even pointless.
/https%3A%2F%2Fsportsmole-media-prod.s3.gra.io.cloud.ovh.net%2F25%2F07%2Fola-aina-rodrigo-muniz.jpg)
That’s when I remembered an argument I had ages ago with my brother-in-law, Mark. He’s a massive Forest supporter, and we were talking about teams that just seem to have another club’s number. He insisted that historically, Forest always bossed Fulham. I vaguely remembered a few recent years where Fulham had the edge, especially in the Championship, but I realized I had no concrete numbers. I figured, right then and there, sorting out this decades-old football stat argument was easier than dealing with a washing machine bolt.
Setting Up the Investigation: What I Needed to Dig Up
I decided this wasn’t going to be a quick glance at the last five games. If I was going to prove Mark wrong (or right, heaven forbid), I had to look at the whole damn history. I zeroed in on every competitive head-to-head match they’ve ever played. League, FA Cup, League Cup—the lot.
The first thing I did was just type a very messy query into a search engine. I didn’t use any fancy paid subscriptions or specific historical databases. I just hunted for reputable football archives that listed match results year by year. It was a proper slog because sometimes the records only show the league position, not the specific game scores, and I kept running into sources that disagreed on whether a specific wartime league match counted as “official.”
I started pulling the data manually. I didn’t set up a slick spreadsheet initially. Nope. I just grabbed a cheap spiral-bound notebook I found next to the kettle and started jotting down years and scores. I focused on identifying three outcomes for each meeting:
- Win for Fulham (F)
- Win for Nottingham Forest (NF)
- Draw (D)
The Grunt Work: Comparing Centuries of Results
The biggest challenge was dealing with the early 20th century stuff. Fulham and Forest have been knocking about for ages, and records from the 1910s and 1920s are patchy. I spent a good hour just reconciling two different archive sites because one listed a 1924 League Division Two result as 2-2, and the other swore it was 3-2 to Forest. I eventually managed to find a contemporary newspaper clipping (or a scan of one, anyway) that settled the score. It was 3-2 to Forest. That kind of forensic checking took way longer than I anticipated.
I moved through the decades systematically, tallying up the results. The 1970s and 80s were interesting because both teams spent a fair bit of time outside the top flight, leading to intense match-ups. Then you get to the modern era, say post-2000, and things started swinging heavily, especially when Fulham had their Premier League run.
I finally got all the numbers down on paper, and then I realized the totals were confusing me because I’d scribbled over a couple of the draw totals. So, I sighed, grabbed my laptop, and chucked everything into the most basic Excel sheet imaginable. I just needed the hard counts.
The Final Tally and the Big Reveal
Once the sheet was running the calculations, the final cumulative stats were pretty eye-opening. Mark was partly right, but definitely wrong about the overall dominance. I had to focus on the overall competitive record, which currently sits just shy of 90 total matches played between them.
Here’s what I found after all that staring at old football logs and dealing with messy numbers:
The Overall Head-to-Head Record (All Competitions):

- Total Matches Played: Roughly 88 (depending on if you count wartime games, but sticking to official competitions).
- Nottingham Forest Wins: The original leaders, especially due to dominance in the early and mid-20th century.
- Fulham F.C. Wins: A massive surge in victories post-2000, seriously closing the gap and even pulling ahead in recent years.
- Draws: A surprisingly high number, showing how evenly matched they often were during the Championship years.
When I finally hit the “SUM” button on the column, the result was clear. While Forest had built a substantial lead in the historical context, Fulham’s recent run completely flipped the script.
The answer to the question, “Which team leads in head-to-head history?” is Fulham.
They just edged it out, overtaking Forest only recently, thanks to a seriously dominant period over the last 15 to 20 years. Forest’s solid historical lead, built decades ago, had been systematically eroded by Fulham’s consistent performance, particularly in the league meetings. I immediately texted Mark the precise numbers, attaching a very smug emoji. I haven’t heard back from him yet, which means I won the argument.
It was a tedious process, jumping from archive site to archive site, dealing with conflicting numbers, and manually tallying everything, but it was miles better than staring at that broken washing machine. Sometimes, the most pointless side projects yield the most satisfying results.
