When people think of Serial, the landmark true crime podcast by Sarah Koenig that debuted in 2014, they might recall the compelling storytelling, the enthralling investigation into Adnan Syed’s case, and the intense narrative style that made it a cultural phenomenon. But what makes a podcast ‘like Serial’? It’s not just its genre or its focus on true crime; it’s how it connects with listeners through its storytelling.
A podcast that echoes Serial engages the audience by turning them into detectives. It doesn’t spoon-feed information but instead invites listeners to think critically, ponder over the details, and form their own theories. This interactive element sits at the core of what makes podcasts compelling — it’s personal, immersive, and lets the listener feel like they’re part of something larger.

Storytelling is the fabric of such shows. They weave narratives that are personal yet universal, drawing listeners in with characters they come to know almost intimately. Not all of these podcasts focus on crime; some delve into mysteries, historical conundrums, or personal journeys. However, the key is in the storytelling — making complex stories digestible and deeply emotional. Podcasts that adopt this approach often spotlight a unique voice or a distinct style, which becomes synonymous with the show itself.
For instance, look at the way ‘S-Town’ unfolds. Though produced by the creators of Serial, its story doesn’t focus on crime but on a dense web of personal life stories from a small town. Here, the podcast’s narrative slowly peels back layers of human complexity, much like Serial did with its crime elements. It’s not just the mystery but the journey, the narrative itself, that captivates the audience.
Authentic voices play a crucial role too. Just as Serial relied heavily on immersive reporting techniques, interviews, and the voice of Sarah Koenig to guide us through the maze of facts and emotions, other podcasts like this seek to maintain a genuine interaction. They often involve real people, not just actors, telling their stories without the veneer of polished scripting. This authenticity fosters a deeper connection between the story and the listener, elevating the narrative from mere entertainment to an educational or enlightening experience.
Moreover, these podcasts engage with real-time developments. While Serial continued to report on the Syed case, many of its successors also keep listeners tuned in to ongoing investigations or personal developments. This approach not only keeps the narrative current but also adds layers of suspense and investment for the audience.
Listeners expect a mix of journalistic integrity, engaging storytelling, and a personal touch from podcasts like Serial. The emphasis on production quality, narrative structure, and the ability to pivot with the story, keeping updates live, shows a commitment to keeping the audience engaged.
This isn’t just about rehashing true crime or unsolved mysteries. The real success of such podcasts, similar to Serial, lies in crafting a narrative that resonates on a human level. Here, listeners find themselves not just as passive consumers but as active participants, pondering over each detail, discussing with others or even supporting investigations.
As listeners, when we press play, we’re not just looking for an agenda — we’re seeking a compelling journey where the end destination might not be as clear cut as we initially thought. The allure of these podcasts lies in their ability to present life’s complexities with clarity, to weave a human story into an artistic endeavor, and to keep us coming back for the next episode, driven by an urge to uncover more fragments of truth. The essence of being ‘like Serial‘ isn’t in replicating the subject matter but in how it touches, provokes, and engages us in a conversation that extends well beyond the confines of its narrative.